April 2000 - abuse of foreigners is not news in Amerikka

Stop Abuse

Follow up
Directory of this site

For the best viewing result
TRIM your browser
"God Father" MIDI

MIDI collection

US Politicians Profit on Immigrant Dreams
April 2000

Elian Gonsales

© Hank Roth

Tue, 25 April 2000 22:19:31 -0400
TheGolem <pnews@gnv.fdt.net>

When the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals made the ruling (which was narrowly decided) that a 6 year old boy could not leave until after the asylum hearing, it created a precedent, which may have a far reaching impact on the INS interpretation and on the disposition of thousands of immigrant children who may be enabled to apply for asylum.

INS said and still maintains that only Elians's father may speak for him, but this three-judge appellate panel noted that the statutes stipulate that "any alien" may apply, without taking into consideration competency of a 6 year old to decide anything for him/herself. If competency is at question, then this opens a whole pandoras box regarding children's rights and applying undo weight to child's rights versus parent's rights in other cases. The pendulum is swinging far too much away from parental rights in favor of children's rights. Both are important, but it has always been prudent to consider experience and acquired knowledge, which cannot be attributed to children or at least must be done so on a case by case basis. The ruling would then also consider politics and anything else the court decides may have a bearing.

It may be a question not to be decided in the courts, but by congress, who in many cases have appeared by their judgement to be less competent than even some 6 year olds.

How can "any alien" be interpreted literally, without consideration of age? If six year olds can decide, why not five year olds, or four year olds, and then who is really deciding, except the courts and on what basis, but politics. Who then is minor with respect to other laws and statutes? This seems to me to be a highly dangerous precedent by the appellate court to make.

A little history: In 1999, the U.S. returned 1,218 (unaccompanied) minors to their countries of origin, including 619 to Mexico, according to the INS. Many legal experts were surprised by this ruling. Family courts have given in the past very little or no weight to similar decisions of six year olds. One must question the motives of the 11th Appellate Court and certainly question their wisdom in making this decision, not least of all the Administrative burden they have imposed on the courts and INS in the future.

How do you feel about it?
Post your replies to the legal and other appropriate message boards:

courtesy Hank Roth © April 2000

Stop The Abuse of Power

Previous Reports
  • Jan 96  Hypocrisy
  • Sep 97  Abolish the INS
  • Jan 98  Total breakdown imminent
  • Feb 98  The INS is still a giant devil
  • Mar 98  The emerging Crisis
  • Apr 98  The INS Scam
  • May 98  The H-1B Crisis
  • June 98 Crisis is FAKE
  • July 98  Set Back Campaign
  • Aug 98  Was there a deal?
  • Sep 98  No Deal!
  • Oct 98  Lifting the H-1B cap
  • Dec 98  Gross Abuse
  • Jan 99  Isn't it slavery?
  • May 99  INS Deports US Citizen
  • June 99  NY police on trial
  • July 99  abuse is not news
  • Aug 99  Proposition 187
  • Oct 99  Abuse of H-1B Workers
  • Dec 99  A Review
  • Jan 00  21st century orverture
  • Feb 00  The visa vendors
  • April 00  This page
  • Aug 00  Are foreign workers a threat?
    Don't  skip  these  pages
  • American Policy Regarding Immigration
  • How do Americans abuse foreigners?
  • Why do Americans abuse foreigners?
  • Apartheid American style

  • References  for further reading
  • Public Opinions

  • My experience in the United States
  • Seeking representation in NJ at U.S. D.C.
  • Read my 1995 article published in Civil-Rights
  • See related articles in PUBPOL  

  • EasyInternet Search

    SIGN Guest Book  |  VIEW Guest Book  |  TRIM your browser

    Directory         Revised April 25, 2000         Page had been Hosted By Geocities Bus

    Copyleft1997-2000 Doron A. Tal - anyhow my rights were lost...         ... דורון א. טל - זכויותי ממילא אבודות